mailservr vs addy.io
addy.io (formerly AnonAddy) is an email forwarding service with a generous free tier and affordable premium plans. Like SimpleLogin, it's forwarding-based — emails are relayed to your real inbox. mailservr takes a different approach with a built-in inbox and one-time pricing.
Pay once, use forever
addy.io charges $1–$4/month subscription. mailservr is a one-time purchase — no recurring fees, no surprise charges. You own it forever after a single payment.
Feature comparison
A detailed look at how mailservr and addy.io compare across key features.
Pricing
Aliases
Domains
Platform
Sending
Why choose mailservr over addy.io
addy.io is great for budget-conscious users who want lots of aliases cheaply. But if you want a self-contained email alias platform with its own inbox and no ongoing costs, mailservr delivers more value with a single payment. Both services integrate with Bitwarden for alias generation.
- Pay once, use forever — never worry about monthly fees again
- Built-in inbox means you don't need a separate email provider
- Threaded conversations keep your email organized
- Send and reply directly from aliases with no forwarding workarounds
- Included storage for emails and attachments
- Compatible with Bitwarden and 1Password for automatic alias generation
Frequently asked questions
Is mailservr better than addy.io?
mailservr offers a built-in inbox and one-time pricing, while addy.io is forwarding-only with a monthly subscription. If you want a complete solution without recurring costs, mailservr is the better fit.
Why does addy.io have more aliases than mailservr?
addy.io offers up to 1,000 aliases on its top tier because it only forwards emails — there's no inbox to host. mailservr includes full email storage and a built-in inbox, so the alias limits are paired with actual mailbox functionality.
Can I switch from addy.io to mailservr?
Yes, you can start using mailservr's shared domains right away. Custom domain support is coming soon — once available, you'll be able to bring your own domains and update your DNS records.
Does addy.io have a built-in inbox?
No. addy.io forwards all emails to your existing email provider. mailservr includes its own inbox where you can read, reply to, and organize emails directly.
Switch from addy.io to mailservr
Pay once and get private email aliases with a built-in inbox and API access. No recurring fees, ever.